When Dr. Gray moved into his ground floor McCormick Hall office, the library and it’s 8,500 volumes were located above him on the second floor. As a result of inquiries addressed to steel tycoon Andrew Carnegie, who was then providing library buildings throughout the country, the college received funding for construction of a new library in 1910. It is interesting to note, however, that when the building was opened as Carnegie Hall, it was more a multi-purpose facility than a library. The manner of its original interior design has been maintained. The institution, consequently, now possesses a library of unique and admired internal appearance.

As one entered the building 70-80 years ago, he or she found the large rooms on the left and right, which are today the offices of the director and the public services & technical librarians, were then classrooms, which also provided space for various Christian, literary, and other organizations to hold their meetings. That is now the main reading room served as a gymnasium which, during the season, hosted intercollegiate basketball games. The basement below featured showers, lockers, storage, and even a concession stand/snack bar.  Spectators for games were seated mostly on the indoor running track which circled the gym. Proudly retained, it is today, so far as can be determined, the only such architectural feature now in an American library. The library itself, moved over from McCormick Hall, was initially contained in one of the two large rooms on the second floor.

Between 1927 when a new gymnasium building was finished and the early 1930s when the first renovation was completed, the functions of the library gradually came to absorb all of Carnegie Hall, which became known as Carnegie Library. By 1939, the library boasted 16,000 volumes, two librarians, and numerous student assistants. Electronics were added in 1942 with the purchase of two phonographs, a new concrete west wing stack area was opened in 1961, and the first computer came in 1982. The remaining second floor office and the last classroom were turned over to the library during the late 1960s. By the 1990s, the library held in excess of 100,000 volumes in paper/microform format. On October 11, 1991, the library was rededicated in honor of Albert Columbus Tate, valedictorian of the 1894 Centennial class and father of Edna Tate Smith of Tallahassee, Florida, a trustee of Tusculum College, in recognition of her generous support as the fourth Benefactor in the long history of the College.